Force Pooling

Editor's note: This was taken from a discussion on GoHaynesvilleShale.com and should not be taken as legal or professional advice; only as opinion
---------------------

As an unleased mineral owner, you will be treated much like a working interest partner, which would be responsible for their share of the well cost, proportionate to what you own in the unit (if you own 32 acres in a 640-acre unit, you would responsible for 5% of the well cost). You can be forced pooled, however, in LA, you cannot be forced to participate (come up with your share in advance), nor can you be penalized for not participating (in that you are not charged more than your share of the well cost for not participating). Generally what this means is that if XYZ Oil Co. drills their well in your unit without your lease, they carry your share of the cost as well as theirs. However, they can net your share of the royalty against your share of the well cost. What this means is until the well pays out (breaks even, or produces more revenue than the well expenses), you won't see a royalty check. After payout, however, you receive your full proportionate share of the revenues. This can stop however, if the operator conducts further operations (reworks, frac jobs,etc.) on the well, to the extent that your share of revenues will be "netted out" against those costs, until those are paid.

---------------------

What does this mean?

---------------------

If the well never pays out, you get nothing. If the well barely pays out, you would have been better signing a lease. If the well is wildly successful, you get lots of revenue, and are admired greatly by your friends (and reviled by others in your unit that 'settled for a lease'). Many people choose to forego all of that and lease. You get a bonus, just for signing the deal. You get a certain percentage of production, period, irrespective of how much the well costs are. And you support the operator by granting leasehold (working interest) to the lessee. The only time that it doesn't 'work out' for you as much as the holdout is if the well goes gangbusters, and you 'settled' for a lease that still will pay you a nice chunk anyway, without the risk. Working interest and net revenue interest are important in that XYZ Oil Co. is going to compare prospects based upon "what's in it for them."

---------------------

As I have told countless landowners, "XYZ Oil Co. is not in the business of drilling and operating a well for YOU." These guys are in it for the money, and the real money is not made my owning and operating wells for the landowner's benefit. And, generally the oil company provides a benefit to you by exploring for and producing minerals that you do not have the time, money or expertise to bring to the market yourself. So if you own 200 acres in a 640-acre unit, and don't lease, no one is going to want to drill a well. There is just not enough financial incentive for them to do so. If you own one acre, two acres, maybe even ten acres (as long as there are not too many like minded owners in your unit), they probably will take the risk, and drill it anyway.

---------------------

As to your question as to 'how will they know to pay you?' I could be flip and say 'How did they know to lease you?' but that's a little too flip for an honest question. XYZ Oil Co. has abstractors (or landmen) run preliminary title to find out who owns what, how much, and where. They lease you based upon that research. Some companies wait to do the full research later (which is why many people receive a draft, this gives XYZ time to prove up the title). At some time between the decision to drill a well and the well coming into production, XYZ Oil Co. makes the decision to commission abstracts to determine full title on the tracts in the unit. This research is handed off to attorneys, who then give a title opinion as to who owns what interest, and who to pay. XYZ then sends out 'division orders' to the identified owners, telling them they own Tract X in the unit, their interest, and a royalty fraction. This fraction times total net production (less taxes and costs applicable to you) from the unit.

---------------------

In LA, you can be force pooled by DNR-Office of Conservation, by Commissioner's order. You cannot be forced to participate, nor can you be "force leased" (this is called integration, and happens in Arkansas).

You also cannot be penalized in multiples of payout (as long as you are not "in the oil business") for being non-consent or unleased, as long as you don't execute a binding contract (like a Joint Operating Agreement), or as long as you don't take and hold the leases yourself (either of which would constitute you "going into the oil business").

---------------------

This is the way this usually works. XYZ Oil Co., identifying you as unleased mineral interest, sends you a division order stating you have 0.xxxxxxxx unleased interest in the unit, asks for correct address and SSN/TIN info, etc. If all the info looks correct, you don't have to really do much. Another letter follows with a well statement, outlining the well costs, your interest, and your share of the costs. You can generally elect to pay them, or have them held out your share of the production.

---------------------

Each month or quarter or so, you will receive a follow up statement (although you should be able to obtain one at anytime as a courtesy) updating the well costs figures and revenue.

Hopefully, you reach payout. Then the statements will shows costs paid in full, and your full share (as UMI or unleased mineral interest) credited from the net proceeds of production.

This is not the same scheme where you choose

(A) "Leased" at $500 and 1/5.

(B) "Leased at $300 and 1/4

(C) Non-consent. (200% penalty) Please make your choice within thirty days. I am working on a DOI sheet right now. There is no column for "non-consent."

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of GoHaynesvilleShale.com to add comments!

Join GoHaynesvilleShale.com

Comment by Two Dogs, Pirate on July 12, 2010 at 13:44
Jamie, you need to give us here on GHS your Section, Township and Range?
Comment by Jamie North on July 12, 2010 at 13:25
Live in Sabine Parish and own 40 acres. We have received notification from a company their intent to apply to drill on the section our property is part of. Of course, we had x amount of days to request a hearing which we did not, nor was made aware of any other land owner who did. My questions (2)...this was approx six months ago, should we expect them to approach us with a option to lease. Should we pursue leasing if this is the route we wish to take?
Comment by Les Bamburg on April 29, 2010 at 3:24
It should be noted that forced pooling is generally applied even when 100% of the acreage in the section is leased as it allows operations to proceed in the unit.
Comment by Ron Jon on April 29, 2010 at 3:05
Metate Creek: There is no force pooling in TX
Comment by GoRicky on April 28, 2010 at 16:28
Looks like a LONG road to a little house. I believe most oil companies in the US now rush in and look for a quick-turnaround on the money invested, with an ultimate low return on their investments, based on casino possibilities. Casinos rely on a steady-as-she-goes business model (like lotteries), based on long-term odds. Mixed in are one-of-a-kind wells and other anomalies. How could the lease bonus be invested & what is the time-value of of the initial monies?

What about a lawsuit over someone getting killed on the location after A well paid out? What about plugging responsibilities? Can the unleased owner just "elect" not to be part of those activities, or is it just an "I'll owe you forever, as I would never try to beat you out of it" situation? What about FUTURE wells in the unit? Must the unleased owner have to maintain records and act on ALL wells after not agreeing to lease? Should the unleased owner expect a guaranteed ultimate increase in profits (over leasing) if the well is " wildly successful" or "gangbusters"? What about your personal estate in LA? Could you pass any unintended consequences on to your children? Is it possible that you could sign a "consulting contract" obligating your heirs long beyond your death, such that the management fees eat up any possible revenues? Are there any limits as to what consultants can charge for those services? What happens if a well (or wells) lose money; such as a big re-vamp of the surface equipment AFTER 1 or more wells recoups its expenses? Are there any federal/state/local tax abatements-advantages that could be overlooked? Should you run the numbers on Earned income as opposed to Un-
earned income? Could it be, through corporate bankruptcy, that this small, legacy working interest owner (or his/her heirs) be responsible for environmental clean-ups mandated by the same authorities that grant abatements? Is it possible that a lien could be attached to your property before your have the chance to "opt-out" & try to let the oil company "cover it all"?

I live in Texas. I'm NOT an expert in LA, BUT, IF I were an unleased mineral owner in LA, I would first take a look at who is telling you NOT to lease, AND I would be taking a look at who is telling you TO lease. Sometimes, BOTH are looking to extract fees and nothing more. My big headache is the liability associated with an acknowledged WORKING INTEREST in wells. No matter how you wish you could shake it off, you can never get away (-hmmm- maybe bankruptcy?) from liability, AND if you sign some sort of long-term management contract, in some cases, it's possible that you have signed away all profits, while you are being told you are "protected". Renting is easy. Ownership is hard. Own at your own risk. Sometimes, you can feel good about owning, AFTER asking hard questions. It just isn't as easy as some people make out is is. Some of these wells will last a long time. Any rash decision will bear the fruits, as always, ONE WAY OR ANOTHER. Good luck with all ---------------
Comment by Johnny on April 28, 2010 at 4:01
I didn't see the well operational overhead from the Joint Operating Agreement mentioned in the costs, just the well cost while figuring payout...

Support GoHaynesvilleShale.com

Not a member? Get our email.

Groups



© 2024   Created by Keith Mauck (Site Publisher).   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service